Key Takeaways:
- France fined Apple €150M for making app tracking harder for advertisers.
- Other European countries are also looking into Apple’s privacy rules.
- Apple says it’s protecting users, but some think it’s unfair to businesses.
Apple is facing trouble in Europe again as French authorities issued a fine of roughly 150 million euros($162 million) because of how it handles app tracking on iPhones and iPads.
The issue is about a feature called App Tracking Transparency (ATT), which Apple says protects user privacy. But regulators argue that it makes things unfair for other companies trying to advertise online.
This fine is also part of the discussion at large about how much power big tech firms should have over digital businesses.
What Is ATT, and Why Is It a Problem?
Apple introduced ATT in 2021, which requires apps to ask permission before tracking users across different websites and apps. If a user says no, the app can’t collect data to show targeted ads.
Apple claims this is to safeguard people’s privacy. However, some French regulators think that ATT has made it harder for smaller companies.
One of the main complaints is that Apple’s system makes users opt out of tracking twice, and this can be quite confusing.
Also, Apple’s own advertising system is not subject to the same restrictions, and some people think this puts them at an unfair advantage.
Many smaller businesses and app developers rely on targeted ads to earn money, they think their ability to compete is hampered by the guidelines of Apple.
Europe Is Watching Apple Closely
France is not the only country looking into Apple’s tracking rules. Germany, Italy, Romania, and Poland are also looking into it to see if it harms competition.
Many European countries want to make sure that big U.S. tech companies do not have too much control over online business and advertising.
This fits into a bigger pattern that Europe is pushing back against tech giants. U.S. companies like Apple, Google, and Meta (Facebook) have faced many fines and lawsuits over the years.
Some U.S. politicians, including President Donald Trump, have even warned that these penalties could lead to trade conflicts between the U.S. and Europe.
How the Industry and Apple Responded
This fine had gotten mixed reactions. Many businesses in the online advertising industry are quite pleased with the decision, saying it helps smaller companies compete.
Organizations like Alliance Digitale and the Internet Advertising Syndicate say that Apple’s rules make it too difficult for businesses to advertise effectively.
On the other hand, Apple disagrees with the fine. The company argues that ATT is supposed to give users more control over their data and that it applies the same rules to all apps, including its own
Apple also pointed out that the French regulators did not force them to change ATT, meaning they can keep using the system as it is for now.
Will This Fine Change Anything for Apple?
While talking about roughly 150 million Euros, it’s a small amount for Apple, which made nearly $400 billion last year. The bigger issue is that more governments are investigating Apple’s business practices.
If multiple countries hand down fines or force changes to Apple to ATT, that could have an even bigger impact on short and long-term plans.
For now, Apple stands firmly by its privacy rules, and the debate over user privacy versus fair competition is far from over.
Read also: Sony & Animoca Bring Anime Fans to Web3 with Soneium Blockchain
